Irresponsible journalism is alive and well in Germany.

During the rally of over 50,000 people against the G 8 in Rostock, the
country’s premier weekly, Der Spiegel, reported on its online edition that
Focus on the Global South Executive Director Walden Bello was inciting
participants to riot. The publication quoted Bello as saying “We have to
bring war to this demonstration.”

Bello said no such thing in his wildly applauded speech. Representatives of
ATTAC, one of the lead organizers of the demonstration, and many others
immediately protested. When Der Spiegel’s editorial board were presented
with a video of Bello speaking, they admitted their error but shifted the
blame to DPA, the German Press Agency, which, they said, filed the story from which they took the wrong quote. According to the Spiegel apology carried
online on June 4, “the correspondent from Der Spiegel in Rostock was in
another site of the demonstration at the time Walden Bello was giving his
speech and could not personally listen to his words.”

The same line from DPA was reproduced in hundreds of newspapers throughout
Germany and Europe and contributed to the perception that violence had been
deliberately fanned by organizers of the largely peaceful but spirited rally.
It was only three days after the event that the main culprit, DPA, retracted
the story and apologized to Bello and the organizers. In an item that went
out on the wires on June 5, the agency said:

“A call to war by one of the speakers at the demonstration in Rostock last
Saturday did not take place. An investigation of the text of the speech
showed that the intervention of Walden Bello had been wrongly translated and
reported by the DPA. DPA regrets the flawed reporting and has apologized to
the organizers.

“In its correspondent’s report about the violence during the demonstration on
June 2, DPA had quoted Bello wrongly as calling for ‘bringing war to the
demonstration because with peaceful means we will achieve nothing.’ Bello
actually said in English: ‘We must bring the war into the discussion because
without peace there can be no justice.’ His demand was in connection with
the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan. The German translation was ‘We need
to bring the war into the discussion because without peace there can be no
fight against poverty.’

Although DPA apologized, the damage already had been done. Organizers of the
G8 Alternative Summit have been very frustrated with the German press’ focus
on the images of disturbances at the margins of Saturday’s largely peaceful
rally and its lack of coverage of the issues relating to global justice that
are being discussed in the week-long affair that is timed with the G8 meeting
in Heiligendamm. There is, indeed, a lively debate on whether the wide
transmission of the mistranslation of Bello’s message was deliberate on the
part of largely conservative German press eager to discredit the alternative
summit.